In light of the Center for Biblical Manhood and Womanhood’s recent release of their “Nashville Statement” (which I’m not going to link to), I feel compelled to speak. So here it is:
I am queer.
If you really want to try to pin it down further, the the best-fitting label I’ve found is biromantic asexual (or bi-ace) — I don’t experience sexual attraction to anyone, but do experience romantic attraction to the same and other genders.
Of course it’s more complicated than that, because when gender identity is basically just a big ??? in my head, “same and other genders” is an imperfect descriptor.
According to the CBMW, my conviction that this “self-conception” is real, created by God, and not inconsistent with Scripture “constitutes an essential departure from Christian faithfulness and witness.”
I don’t…I don’t really know where to go from there. I’ve typed a number of different things, considered a number of different directions. All I’ve really got is hurt and frustration.
The entire statement frames queerness as being essentially about sexual desire and behavior, but that’s not my experience. As an ace person, I don’t experience sexual desire, but I am still queer. I am still queer because I experience the world differently than straight, cisgender folks. I am queer because I exist outside the gender binary our society, and evangelicalism, has decided is an essential part of humanity.
Do you see why this hurts? The CBMW says “this is what it means to be human, this is what it means to be created by God, this and only this is the imago dei” — and it doesn’t describe me. To earn their stamp of approval, I would not have to just “resist sinful temptation,” but actively reject who I am.
I tried that. I tried for years to mold myself/be molded by God into a “biblical woman.” I studied and I read and I prayed and I twisted myself into knots over it. I told myself that my discomfort in that role was about my weight or my insecurity or my ego, that my inability to grasp what people even meant by “biblical womanhood” was a flaw of my own understanding.
In my years as the evangelical youth group poster child, I never even entertained the thought that I could be anything other than a straight girl. I was too busy using doctrine to sneer at those other “lesser” denominations and churches and using apologetics to argue people over to my side (or rather, worrying that my tendency to be “too nice” was cowardice and that Jesus was ashamed of me and my friends were going to hell).
Being gay was a choice, you know? In 9th grade biology, I learned that there are two sexes and of course sex and gender are the same thing — why wouldn’t they be?
I had a “true love waits” ring and as soon as I could lose some weight and figure out how to turn sarcasm into meekness, Jesus would bring me the man of my dreams and we would stay married forever no matter what (I would never have said this out loud, of course — I knew better — but the messages and beliefs were still there).
But even at my thinnest and meekest, that never happened. Even though I tried to embody femininity (even after I cut my hair short), I was never very good at it, and then I felt guilt and shame for not being good at it. I desperately wanted to make it work, but it never did. It was exhausting.
When I realized how much I preferred the way I looked and felt in a hat and a t-shirt to the way I looked and felt in all my cute dresses, it terrified me. When I connected the way I felt about a girl at church to the way I felt about boys I had had crushes on, it terrified me. Even though I had already moved towards an egalitarian and affirming theology, the idea of applying that to myself felt like standing on the edge of cliff.
Ultimately, it was being an ally that gave me the freedom to discover and be myself. I firmly believe that God led me to those theological positions so that God could show me who I was created to be. But I have agonized over every step of that journey.
And on every step of that journey, I have been surrounded by voices telling me that I was wrong. That I was denying who God created me to be. That I was making God in my own image. That I was prioritizing my own desires over truth. That I was turning a blind eye to sin. That I was conforming to the world, being unthinkingly led by society. That they were telling me all of these things out of love.
I have stayed in the evangelical church longer than most would expect for an LGBTQ-affirming egalitarian. I have tried to be a bridge — I came from the complementarian, non-affirming side, so I understand that side. I have tried to live with “agree to disagree,” even though doing so often felt like condoning violence against my friends and subjecting myself to that violence as well, because I believed that one day I might see a shift, was already starting to see a shift.
But it’s exhausting. I sit next to people who think that my very existence is sinful every Sunday morning. In small groups, I watch my words because I’m not sure I’d be welcome if I were completely honest, but I need the community. I work with people who would sign the Nashville Statement in a heartbeat; at least one of them has already posted it on Facebook, excited to have a “biblical explanation of sexuality.” I teach students who return books with gay characters to the library because they don’t want to read that “nasty stuff.”
It all adds up; it all weighs on me. But up to this point, I have endured it because I felt like my voice and my presence in those spaces could be useful.
And now the CBMW has declared that even “agreeing to disagree” is sinful. That to do so is to place oneself outside of the Christian community. That there can be no meeting in the middle, that there can be no bridge building — either I come to their side, or I’m out. That the best way my church family can love me is to deny my Christian witness until I repent of being who I am.
I can tell myself over and over again that their approval doesn’t matter, that John Piper and Matt Chandler and Francis Chan, men who I have read and listened to and respected, do not get to decide my standing before God. But that doesn’t change the fact that evangelicalism kicked me out. I may have already been mostly out the door, but that rejection still stings.
And I’m an adult with friends that I am out to who love me for exactly who I am. No one is going to kick me out of my apartment and I am relatively sure I will not be fired from my job for coming out.
I can’t imagine being a transgender kid and seeing that pastors have told my parents it would be sinful to not misgender me. I can’t imagine being a queer kid and knowing that if my parents support me, they will be considered outside the bounds of Christian faithfulness. I can’t imagine being a teenager and wanting to follow Jesus, but being told that doing so requires that I condemn myself to a lifetime of loneliness, without any chance at romantic love (it’s hard to hear that at 31; I imagine it would be excruciating at 15).
Other people have already begun writing about the problems with the theology and hermeneutics of the Nashville Statement. Other people have been writing for years about how the fruit of this theology is regularly and consistently fear, shame, self-harm, and brokenness.
What I want my friends and family reading to understand is that this is not an abstract “issue”. This is my life. This is my every day. And while you might be able to read the Nashville Statement and nod and move on with your day, I have not been able to stop thinking about it since I read it.
And it hurts. It really, really hurts.
Note: I wrote the first draft of this the morning after the Nashville Statement was released. I wasn’t sure if I was going to post it, not because I’m ashamed, but because I wasn’t sure I was ready to face the consequences that may come from it. Ultimately, I decided that if writing this has even a miniscule chance of moving us closer to a world where people don’t need to write things like this, it’s worth it.
